Hobbyman2007 wrote:
If the squirrels arround here start wearing armour , I'll buy more. Until then domes are good enough. Pretty impressive none the less what the do at 650 fps.
X2.
Does one usefully have to measure pellet damage when shooting brass shells, or is it just sufficiently cool to know they were accurate enough to hit the target shells? If you have an air gun suitably rated for your quarry at an acceptable distance, does the shot really require more than a domed pellet? My answer, after trying original and metal polymags is
no: they do not give you any more
apparent "killing power" than equally accurate domes. The exception may be in, say, .25 cal, when you're trying to kill a 'coon or another pesty beast outside the recommended varmint category of the gun. Generally, they do give you the advantage of knowing your carefully placed shot will, perhaps, more definitely give you a clean kill.
People shooting paper or small pests should not invest in Polymags other than just because the brand name is cool. In the process of using up my remaining Polymags (both metal and original), I can foresee little pleasure because the "bang for buck" is generally inferior to my preferred domed pellets. Here's my summary assessment:
- Polymags are not cheap; they are generally 20-35% more expensive than quality domed pellets
- Polymags are considered by many/most to be very accurate pellets.
- Polymag pellets are designed for shooting small/medium game/pests.
- Polymag pellets, by general reputation, which was built from skillful marketing, are considered a more "destructive" varmint pellet.
- Polymag pellets have a "cool" factor and are worth a try, just because every air gunner should.
- Polymag pellets have never been proven (by actual, game-shooting demonstration) to be superior to domed pellets (in a typical kill/no kill challenge).
Summary:Polymags are rarely, if ever, worth more than an equally accurate/consistent domed pellet in most shooting experiences; enhanced shrapnel (if any, affected by FPS and target make-up) is typically not a significant factor. Given equal costs, proven-compatible domed pellets
should be given the edge in target situations, and Polymags
may be given the edge in small game/pest hunting situations when proven as accurate as the domed pellet.